Scarborough is a fantastic place for dining out, as there is such a diverse range of restaurants to choose from, including options to suit all tastes and budgets. One of the most popular cuisines is Italian, and there are plenty of Scarborough Italian restaurants to try. So, which are the best Italian restaurants in Scarborough? Here are our recommendations for the best Italian restaurants to try in Scarborough based on their menus, food quality, customer feedback, and overall dining experience.
The Best Italian Restaurants in Scarborough
Lanterna Restaurant: The Best Italian Restaurant in Scarborough Overall
One of the best Italian restaurants in Scarborough is Lanterna, so you should put it at the top of your list of places to try. It is also one of the best restaurants in Scarborough overall. Although it is an Italian restaurant that predominantly serves Piedmontese cuisine, the dishes have Yorkshire influences, and many local ingredients are used in their preparation. The downside to this establishment is the limited opening hours.
- Address: 33 Queen Street, Scarborough, YO11 1HQ
- Telephone: 01723 363616
- Website: http://lanterna-ristorante.co.uk/menu.html
- Opening hours: Closed from Sunday to Wednesday, open from 7 pm to 9.30 pm Thursday to Saturday
Pepe Verde: Best Italian Takeaway in Scarborough
If you prefer to order a takeaway rather than dine in a restaurant, then one of the best places to get Italian food in Scarborough is Pepe Verde. Unlike some Italian takeaways that only serve pizzas, the takeout menu from Pepe Verde includes a wide range of Italian dishes, including pasta. All the dishes are made fresh to order using high-quality ingredients.
- Address: 35 Huntriss Row, Scarborough, YO11 2ED
- Telephone: 01723 373388
- Website: http://www.pepeverde.uk/
- Opening hours: Closed on Monday, open from 4.30 pm to 9.30 pm Tuesday to Sunday
Embers: One of the Best Italian Restaurants in Scarborough for Tapas and Cocktails
Embers has earned an outstanding reputation for serving a simple menu of delicious Italian food. They also offer a tapas-style menu, which means you can sample several different dishes. Embers also have a great cocktail menu if you fancy something different to Italian wines or beer to accompany your meal.
- Address: 138 Victoria Road, Scarborough, YO11 1SL
- Telephone: 01723 267104
- Website: http://embers.restaurant/
- Opening hours: Closed Sunday to Tuesday, open from 5 pm to 9 pm Wednesday to Friday and 12 noon to 3 am Saturday
Castello Pizzeria Bar: Some of Scarborough’s Best Pizzas
Castello Pizzeria Bar is predominantly a takeaway, although there is a small seating area for those who prefer to dine in and enjoy their pizza. Many regulars say that Castello Pizzeria Bar makes some of Scarborough’s best pizzas, and a good selection of toppings is available.
- Address: 14 Victoria Road, Scarborough, YO11 1SD
- Telephone: 07706778602
- Website: https://castellopizzeriabar.com/order-now
- Opening hours: Closed Monday and Tuesday, open from 5 pm to 9.30 pm on Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday, and from 5 pm to 10 pm on Friday and Saturday
Pizza Tempo: One of Scarborough’s Top Italian Takeaways
There are rave reviews for the pizza and calzone from Pizza Tempo, which is why it is known as one of Scarborough’s best takeaways. They offer a delivery service if you cannot collect your order yourself.
- Address: 90 Falsgrave Road, Scarborough, YO12 5AZ
- Telephone: 01723 369060
- Opening hours: Open from 4.30 pm to 11 pm every day except closed on Tuesday
Tuscany Too: One of the Best Italian Restaurants in Scarborough for Customer Service
One feature of dining out at Tuscany Too that makes it stand out from the local competition is the customer service, as diners say the staff are attentive and friendly. However, the standard of the food is another reason to dine at this restaurant. There is an excellent selection of Italian dishes, with something to suit all tastes.
- Address: 6 Filey Road, Scarborough, YO11 2SD
- Telephone: 01723 355900
- Opening hours: Closed on Sundays, 9 am to 9.30 pm Mondays, and 5.30 pm to 9.30 pm Tuesdays to Saturdays
Il Piatto Italian Restaurant: One of the Best Modern Italian Restaurants in Scarborough
There is a minimalist feel at Il Piatto Italian Restaurant due to interior features such as leather chairs and a stripped floor. The menu consists of typical Italian dishes served in a modern way. Diners say that the prices are reasonable. If you do not want to dine in the restaurant, you can order a takeaway, although they do not offer a delivery service.
- Address: 4 Harcourt Place, Scarborough, YO11 2EP
- Telephone: 07921101166
- Website: http://il-piattoitaliano.co.uk/
- Opening hours: Open from 5 pm to 9 pm Sunday to Thursday, except closed on Mondays, and from 5 pm to 10 on Fridays and Saturdays
Gianni’s Italian Restaurant: A Family-Run Italian Restaurant
Gianni’s Italian Restaurant is a well-established, family-run business in Scarborough that is a favourite amongst the locals. The dining room has a Venetian theme, and there is a chic bar area. Diners say the food is competitively priced, and the service is excellent. Although there is no delivery, there is the option to order takeout from the restaurant.
- Address: 13 Victoria Road, Scarborough, YO11 1SB
- Telephone: 01723 507388
- Website: http://www.giannisrestaurant.co.uk/content/menu.aspx
- Opening hours: Closed on Sundays, open from 4.30 pm to 11 pm, Mondays to Saturdays
Crema Cioccolato: Best Italian Restaurant in Scarborough for Ice Cream
Crema Cioccolato is an Italian restaurant with a difference. It is a coffee shop and dessert bar that serves authentic Italian ice cream. Therefore, it is one of the best Italian restaurants in Scarborough to visit if you like Italian-style ice cream and cakes. They also serve some savoury Italian bar food.
- Address: 43 Scarborough, YO11 1NF
- Telephone: 01723 658867
- Website: http://www.theitalianjobltd.uk/
- Opening hours: Open from 12 noon to 6 pm every day except Tuesdays and Wednesdays
Café Italia: Best Italian Café in Scarborough
For those who want to eat Italian food during the day, one of the best Italian restaurants in Scarborough is Café Italia. It serves authentic Italian cuisine, and the Italian coffee is superb. The café is a lovely place to watch the world go by while you take a break from shopping or sightseeing in Scarborough.
- Address: 36 St Nicholas Cliff, Scarborough, YO11 2ES
- Telephone: 01723 501973
- Opening hours: Closed Sunday to Tuesday, open from 10 am to 3 pm Thursday to Saturday
Florio’s Pizzeria
If you are a fan of pizza, then one of the best options in Scarborough is Florio’s Pizzeria. However, pizzas are not the only dishes on the menu, as there is a wide range of Mediterranean cuisine. There is also a children’s menu for younger diners. Customers can dine in or order takeaway, although there is no delivery service.
- Address: 35-37 Aberdeen Walk, Scarborough, YO11 1BD
- Telephone: 01723 351124
- Website: https://www.floriosscarborough.co.uk/our-menu
- Opening hours: Open from 5 pm to 9 pm Sunday to Thursday, except closed on Tuesday, and from 5 pm to 9.30 pm on Friday and Saturday
George Michael’s Restaurant: Diverse Mediterranean Offerings
Strictly speaking, it would be better to describe George Michael’s Restaurant as a Mediterranean eatery rather than an Italian restaurant in Scarborough, as there are Italian, French, British, and Greek dishes on the menu. Customers praise the friendly staff and excellent service. The restaurant is inside the Castle Health Centre.
- Address: 5 York Place, Scarborough, YO11 2NP
- Telephone: 01723 372646
- Website: http://www.gmrestaurant.co.uk/Menu/
- Opening hours: Closed on Sunday and Monday, open from 5.30 pm to 10 pm Tuesday to Saturday
Regano Pizzeria & Grill
The menu at this takeaway includes pizzas, pasta, calzones, and wraps. There are also a couple of desserts on the menu, including tiramisu. All the food is freshly prepared, and customers say it is delicious.
- Address: 24 Falsgrave Road, Scarborough, YO12 5AT
- Telephone: 01723 381111
- Website: https://reganopizzeriaandgrill.co.uk/kIMf
- Opening hours: Closed on Monday, open from 4 pm to 10 pm Tuesday to Sunday
Pomodoro Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Pomodoro Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a cosy bistro in Scarborough that serves Italian dishes created by the Alba-born chef. Diners describe the food as authentic Italian and say the restaurant serves some of the best pizza in Scarborough.
- Address: 24-25 Newborough, Scarborough, YO11 1NA
- Telephone: 01723 507336
- Website: http://www.pomodoropizzeria.co.uk/
- Opening hours: 12 noon to 2 pm and 5 pm to 9 pm, seven days a week
If you are in Scarborough and you do not feel like eating Italian food, you might like to read our articles about Chinese, Indian, and vegan restaurants in Scarborough. You should also read about the best hotels in Scarborough if you intend to stay for a couple of days.
Have you visited any of these Italian restaurants in Scarborough? Do you agree with our selections? Let us know in the comments section below.